Words With No Transferable Skills

An Investigation into the Career Paths of English Words


The Problem With Knell

Most of my article ideas begin with people behaving strangely.

Occasionally they begin with me behaving strangely.

This is one of those occasions.

Last September, I was listening to coverage of the Toronto Blue Jays' increasingly theoretical playoff chances. The season was winding down. The teams ahead of them kept winning. The Jays couldn’t seem to string together two or three wins, let alone the sustained run they needed to keep pace. The available paths to the post-season were vanishing one by one.

It eventually got to the point where the Jays would need to win every remaining game and hope that a few strategically selected American League cities were struck by asteroids.

Anyway, it was around this point that I heard a sports broadcaster use the words death knell to punctuate the ominous inevitability of the team's fate.

Not unusual. Sports commentators say dramatic things all the time. A baseball team loses three games in a row and suddenly we're discussing destiny, heartbreak, collapse, resilience, redemption, and occasionally the end of civilization.

What caught my attention wasn't the death part.

It was the knell.

Specifically: what exactly is a knell?

I knew what death knell meant. Everybody knows what death knell means.

It's one of those phrases that arrives in your brain as a complete package, evoking the soundscape of a bell ringing.

But if someone simply said, "I heard a knell this afternoon," I'd immediately have questions.

Starting with: Is this person an English professor, or a Victorian ghost?

Followed by: Has anybody heard a knell recently?

Then: Can you just have a knell?

Which inevitably led me to ask: Is knell a fully functioning word on its own, or does it spend its entire career attached to the word death like a highly specialized employee who only knows one software package?

These were questions that did not need answering.

At all.

Unfortunately, they were now questions I had.

And that is how I discovered something called a fossil word.

Still On Probation

Naturally, I did what any reasonable person would do after becoming distracted by a single word in a baseball broadcast.

I looked it up.

As it turns out, a knell is a bell rung slowly, traditionally to mark a death, funeral, disaster, or some other decidedly cheerful occasion.

Which means death knell is one of those phrases with the omen already built in. A knell, by itself, is already associated with endings, misfortune, and sombre bell-ringing.

So the strange part isn't what the word knell means.

The strange part is how rarely we encounter the word by itself.

You rarely hear someone say:

"I say, that was a first-rate knell we heard at the Pope’s funeral."

That's not a sentence most of us encounter.

Nor is it one most of us would hear without raising an eyebrow.

At any rate, the word remains alive, but it appears to have settled into a remarkably narrow line of work.

That discovery led me to another term I had never encountered before: fossil word.

A fossil word is a word that survives primarily, and sometimes almost exclusively, within a particular phrase or expression, usually alongside one other word.

It's not necessarily obsolete. It's not necessarily extinct. It just doesn't get out much. And when it does, it needs to be chaperoned by one other word.

The same word.

Every time.

After several hundred years, you'd think it could be trusted to work unsupervised.

Some fossil words have become so attached to a particular linguistic companion that it's difficult to imagine them apart:

  • knell in death knell

  • fro in to and fro

  • ado in without further ado or much ado

  • kith in kith and kin

  • beck in beck and call

  • bated in bated breath

Some of these words can still be found elsewhere if you really go looking for them. Language, as usual, refuses to organize itself into neat categories.

But if I stopped a random person on the street and asked them to use kith in a sentence without using the word kin, I suspect the response would consist largely of blinking and a confused stare.

Or they might say that their favourite KITH skits are the ones where Scott Thompson imitates Queen Elizabeth.

Anyway, that's what fascinated me: that the English language contains words that seem to exist almost exclusively beside another word.

The Fossil Word Employment Program

The more I thought about fossil words, the less they seemed like words and the more they seemed like employees.

Not unemployed employees.

Long-tenured and extremely specialized employees.

If the dictionary were a company, then fossil words would be the people who've held the same position for hundreds of years and have no intention of updating their résumé.

Fossil Word Employee Profile

Name: dulcet
Current Position: Precedes the word “tones”
Definition: Sweet
Years of Service: Approximately 580
Other Duties: Originally used to describe things that taste sweet. This responsibility has since been abandoned in favour of focusing exclusively on auditory sensations.

That's the résumé for the word dulcet.

No certifications. No professional credentials. No transferable skills. No evidence of professional growth.

And there are plenty of other examples.

Beck has apparently been on call with call since the Middle Ages.

A caboodle would be entirely lost without a kit by its side.

Time is really the only thing anyone ever seems willing to bide.

The remarkable thing is that none of these words appears remotely interested in branching out.

They've found a niche and settled into it with the assuredness of someone who's been doing the same job since Henry VIII was in knee socks, and they fully intend to die at their desk.

Why Things Will Never Change

So maybe the real question isn't why fossil words exist.

Maybe the real question is why they stay fossilized.

After hundreds of years, why doesn't one of them decide to try something new?

I blame senior management.

Nobody at Merriam-Webster has ever approached a fossil word and said, "We think it's time you started job-shadowing some other words."

Just think about it.

When was the last time you heard of someone wreaking tranquility?

Or strolling amok?

No one has ever exhibited sleight of feet. Not even Fred Astaire.

And I've yet to encounter anyone who wanted a partial shebang of anything.

Some words simply refuse reassignment.

Umbrage is always taken, never given.

A riddance is never bad, excellent, or mediocre. Just good.

A petard exists solely to hoist the unfortunate schmo attempting to use it against someone else.

And neither helter nor skelter is even willing to work independently. They only appear together, making each one the chaperone of the other. It's like leaving two seven-year-old boys in charge of each other and hoping their combined sense of responsibility somehow cancels out their combined capacity for mayhem.

The Fossil Word Social Club

At some point, I realized I was no longer researching fossil words.

I was wondering whether they were happy.

This was not a productive development.

Modern career advice tells us to reinvent ourselves. Learn new skills. Broaden our horizons. Embrace change.

Meanwhile, bated has spent hundreds of years doing one thing and one thing only. It describes something that is subdued or restrained. It is never used with words like speech, anger, excitement, or violence.

Just breath.

The word has a plan and sees no reason to complicate matters.

I began to wonder whether the fossil words know they're fossil words.

Does kith ever get tired of standing beside kin?

Does umbrage secretly wish somebody would give it for a change instead of constantly taking it?

Does beck ever wonder what life would have been like if it had pursued opportunities outside of call?

Most importantly, does knell know that it was the reason I stopped paying attention to a baseball game?

Because if it does, I suspect it's enormously pleased with itself.

The English language contains hundreds of thousands of words.

Most spend their lives competing for attention.

Fossil words don't seem interested in the competition.

They secured a tiny patch of linguistic real estate several centuries ago and have stubbornly refused to leave.

Maybe they've figured something out.

Although I suspect bated would just tell you to take a subdued, restrained breath.

The Lasting Legacy of Knell

The Blue Jays, unsurprisingly, failed to make the playoffs.

I don't remember the score of the game.

I don't remember any of the details that were likely important at the time.

What I do remember is spending several days investigating the employment history of a bell-related noun.

Words can be weird or unexpected.

The word non-hyphenated is hyphenated. The word monosyllabic is polysyllabic. And the word thesaurus has no synonyms whatsoever.

And fossil words are no different. They’re strange in their own way.

They survive not because they're common.

They survive only because they’ve found a permanent companion.

So people just continued saying them.

And centuries later, these words are still being used.

Still doing the same job.

Now whenever I hear the phrase death knell, I don't think about impending doom.

I think about knell.

Still refusing to acquire a marketable skill beyond standing beside the word death, despite having had several centuries to do so.

That may not be a useful talent.

But on the bright side, if the English language ever needs someone to check in on the fossil words, I already have experience.

Which means that when that time comes, at least I won't be taken aback.



Like what you read? I write, rewrite, overthink, rewrite again, and eventually post these things in hopes they resonate. If something struck a chord, sparked an idea, or — most importantly — made you laugh, please drop a comment below. Sarcasm is welcome, cruelty is not. So be honest, and be nice. It’s possible to do both.

And if you'd like to support the effort (or just bribe me to keep going), you can buy me a coffee. No pressure — but caffeine is a powerful motivator.

Full disclosure: you can’t actually make me buy a coffee with your donation. I might use it for a beer instead.

Next
Next

Todd’s Unifying Theory of Pointless Human Behaviour, Part 2